Pookies In Crime

E24 - Nick Nickelson and Ceck Crock the Croc

Thu, 18 Sep 2025 11:00:41 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! After taking a little break, we're back!

Aside from meeting Edgar, the new haunted chimpanzee that lives in Aria's room, we cover two mildly disturbing cases today: first, Ava covers the top five most creepy things at Disneyland, and Aria follows it up with the horrifying murder of Helle Crafts.

Thanks for listening! Follow, rate, and share!

E23 - My Friend the Crayfish and Liminal Planes

Thu, 11 Sep 2025 11:00:56 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! Aria starts us off with the disappearance of Frederick Valentich, who's only friends were crayfish (relatable). Ava finishes it up with the very unsettling case of the Decker Children Killings.

Check out our socials, and remember to watch those YouTube short videos, just in case you get stuck in a mall with moving mannequins!

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E22 - My Little Pony and Frank Paradise

Thu, 04 Sep 2025 13:17:34 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! This week, Ava follows up on her Slenderman lore with the Slenderman Stabbings, AKA the Attempted Murder of Bella Leutner. Aria follows up with the story of Pocatello High School, the most haunted high school in the US, who's architect was totally a famous pop star.

Thanks for tuning in! Rate, share, and follow!

E21 - Undead Warriors of Garlic and James Charles the Skinwalker

Thu, 28 Aug 2025 11:00:02 +0000

Welcome to Pookies in Crime! Today, the pookies cover two urban legends- John and Wayne Carter (not John Wayne Gacy), and the Slenderman, who is probably James Charles. They both like makeup, they're both kings, and they both prey on children!

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E20 - Dangerous Chickens and Drug Dealing Babies

Thu, 21 Aug 2025 11:00:07 +0000

Welcome to Episode 20! Today, Ava finishes her two parter on Walter Collins, and Aria finishes her two parter on the Midtown Jane Doe, Patricia McGlone.

If you know anything about the Patricia McGlone case, please contact 800-577-TIPS or the NYPD.

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E19 - Moonshine Ice Cream and Three Haunted Toilets

Thu, 14 Aug 2025 11:00:02 +0000

Welcome to our first ever double two parter! Aria starts us off with the unsolved case of the Midtown Jane Doe, which is probably one of the most red-herring heavy cases we've ever covered, and this is just part one! Ava finishes with part one of the disappearance of Walter Collins.

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E18 - Evil German Priests and Vacationing in Italy

Thu, 07 Aug 2025 11:00:28 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! Today, Ava covers the exorcism of Annaliese Michel, in which a very evil (and very real) priest named Fleischmann possesses a twenty year old girl. Aria follows it up with the TV drama disappearance of Dorothy Arnolds.

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E17 - Zebulon's New Pookie and The Wind

Thu, 31 Jul 2025 11:00:30 +0000

Welcome to Episode 17! We are so sorry for any audio issues, we're not quite sure what was happening. It's possible it was Bryun, or the window was open and we just don't remember. Anyway, today Aria tells the story of the Stanford Prison Experiment, which was very interesting psychologically, but very disturbing in every other way. Ava follows it up with the disappearance of Sierra LaMar, in which a man "straight up jorks it in the car." Tune in next week to hear more, and share with your friends!

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E16 - Ben Franklin in Stranger Things and a Cryptid With Strong Thighs

Thu, 24 Jul 2025 11:00:14 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! This week, Ava covers the case of the Hellfire Cave Murder and the haunting that follows. Aria follows it up with a very creepy pair of pants... the Fresno Nightcrawlers. Could they be aliens? Could they be sandhill cranes? Or are they just an undiscovered primate that has no torso? Find out now, and tune in next week for another episode!

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E15 - A Puddle PSA and Pissing Brad

Thu, 17 Jul 2025 15:30:27 +0000

Sorry for the late upload! We really need to stop procrastinating, but that's a problem for a different day. Today, Ava covers the case of The Dollmaker, who has some extremely weird similarities to Aria. Aria follows it up with the unsolved case of William Bradford Bishop, who was last seen peeing in a bathroom in Italy.

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E14 - A Conse-quiche and a Double Bryun Encounter

Thu, 10 Jul 2025 11:00:44 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime, where we discuss all things horror! This week, Aria starts us off with the psychologically disturbing case of the Phoenix Canal Murders, also known as the Zombie Hunter Killings. Ava finishes it off with the tragic and monetized case of Gabby Petito. And is Aria's basement haunted?

Remember, if this gets to 200 streams, we'll do a ghost hunt in Aria's basement!

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E13 - Joseph Smith Reincarnated and Jesus's High School Clique

Thu, 03 Jul 2025 11:00:06 +0000

Welcome to Pookies in Crime! Today, after discussing various fnaf and hashbrown related topics, Ava starts us off with the extremely uncanny missing persons case of Ryker Webb. Aria follows it up with a little culty wulty, the Brother Twelve Cult- also known as the Super Smash Bros of religion. Thanks for tuning in!

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E12 - Phineas, Ferb, and a Feminist Clown Killer

Thu, 26 Jun 2025 11:00:50 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! Sorry in advance for audio issues, we were recording in Ava's basement, and she has three younger siblings...

Today, Aria covers the psychologically disturbing case of Marlen Warren, and Ava follows it up with the even more psychologically disturbing case of the "Alphabet Murders."

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Share, rate, and follow!

E11 - Ninjago Talk and Our New Friend Michael

Thu, 19 Jun 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Welcome to our most chaotic episode yet! From recording each half a week apart to sound issues to editing this the day before it comes out, it's been a hectic time!

This week, Ava covers the death of Satomi Mitarai, a story that shows us how media can influence children to the extreme. Aria then, after a brief intermission, covers the ghostly haunting of the Crescent Hotel.

Instagram: @pookies_incrime

Email: pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Send us stories, rate, and share! Thanks for tuning in.

E10 - A Musical Mixtape and A Crossover from Mothman

Thu, 12 Jun 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Welcome back! For our tenth episode, Aria covers the Tom-on-Tom murder of Tom Meyers, the sequel to last episode's musical. Ava covers the spooky case of Annabelle the Haunted Doll!

Email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com

DM us at @pookies_incrime

Tune in next Thursday!

E9 - the TED Bundy Talk and the Entrance of George Harrison

Thu, 05 Jun 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Welcome to Pookies in Crime! This week, Ava covers the case of Cassie Stoddart, a completely unnecessary murder by two douche bags. After that, Aria covers the mildly hilarious case of Clement Vallindigham.

If you'd like to send in a listener story, DM us on Instagram with @pookies_incrime or email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com

Thanks for tuning in!

E8 - A Plethora of Mandolins and the Sandhill Crane 2.0

Thu, 29 May 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Welcome to today's episode! Aria covers the case of the Dyatlov pass, in which there is a surprising amount of mandolins. After that, Ava covers the lore and history behind moth man, who may or may not be the return of the sandhill crane.

If you'd like to send in a listener story or recommendation, email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com or DM us on Instagram at @pookies_incrime

E7- A Sad TIred Episode and Being Like the Other Girls

Thu, 22 May 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Today, Ava covers the extremely disturbing case of Brenda Ann Spencer and what has been coined today as "The Monday Shootings." Aria follows it up with the unsolved, not well known case of Kay Medin.

If you liked this episode, rate and subscribe! DM us on instagram at @pookies_incrime or email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com to send in listener stories!

E6 - Dororthy "Rex" Gale and A Pond Full of Girlfriends

Thu, 15 May 2025 11:00:00 +0000

This week, Aria finishes her second story on the Rebel Without a Cause Curse, while Ava covers the slightly badass story of a whole town teaming up to get rid of a common enemy- Kenneth Rex McElroy.

Please rate and subscribe if you liked this episode! DM us at @pookies_incrime on Instagram, or email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com with listener stories or recommendations.

See you next Thursday!

E5 - A Demonic Sandhill Crane and the First Bisexual Icon

Thu, 08 May 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Today, Ava catches up on the paranormal side of things with the Flannan Isle Lighthouse disappearances, while Aria covers the first episode on the Rebel Without A Cause Curse.

If you liked this episode, subscribe and rate! DM us at pookies_incrime on Instagram or email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com if you'd like to send in a listener recommendation!

E4 - Bad Twlight Fanfiction and Henry VIII's Gay Alien Lover

Thu, 01 May 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Today, Aria covers the story of the first (and surprisingly not only) woman who claimed to have had a sexual relationship with an alien- who was also 2,000 years older than her (ew). On a more (or less?) disturbing note, Ava covers the case of murder of John and Lois McCullough.

If you liked this episode, share, rate and subscribe! If you'd like to send in a listener episode, email us at pookies_incrime@gmail.com

@pookies_incrime on instagram

Thanks for listening!

E3 - My Arugula Boyfriend and Hell's Grody Wi-Fi

Thu, 24 Apr 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Aside from learning about Aria's new boyfriend, a vegetable, we look into the frustratingly unsolved death of Elisa Lam, as well as the very preventable death of Lauren McCluskey.

If you enjoyed this, please rate, subscribe, and follow us on Instagram at @pookies_incrime

If you'd like to send in a listener story, please email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com

E2 - Ed Gein's Fruit Roll Up and Crop Rotating Shrooms

Thu, 17 Apr 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Welcome to Episode 2 of Pookies In Crime! Today, Aria covers the "Lost Girls of Panama" case, AKA the disappearance of Kris Kremmers and Lisanne Froon. Ava covers the case of university professor turned recluse, the Corspewood Manor Murders.

If you liked this episode, please rate and subscribe! If you're interested in sending in a listener story, please email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com, or DM us at @pookies_incrime on Instagram.

Thanks for listening!

E1 - Rat Terriers and a Horse Girl Supreme

Thu, 10 Apr 2025 11:00:00 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime! Today, Ava covers the insane (and disturbing) case of Bobbie Jo Stinnett, and Aria covers the recently solved case of Yvonne Menke.

If you enjoy this podcast, please rate and subscribe! If you'd like to send in a listener story or a case recommendation, please email us at pookiesincrime@gmail.com, or DM us at @pookies_incrime on instagram.

Thanks for listening!

Pookies In Crime Trailer

Sun, 06 Apr 2025 01:39:00 +0000

Welcome to Pookies In Crime!