Take Aways

• Investigate the breakdown of the initial legal proceedings against the man last seen with Teresa.
• Examine the suspect’s behavior and personality, including his history of instability and unusual fixations.
• Discuss how the Bigfoot theory served as a distraction from the victim and the potential crime.
• Analyze the three main theories surrounding Teresa’s disappearance: the Bigfoot theory, the suspect’s culpability, and a connection to the “Speed Freak Killers.”
• Consider the lasting impact of the unsolved case on Teresa’s family and the broader implications for similar cases.

DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBEJOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA BY FOLLOWING THE ⁠LINKTREE⁠Follow Our Family Of True Crime Shows. Every podcast is important. We hope you join us on our important missions!⁠Lost Girls ⁠

⁠True Crime,Authors & Extraordinary People⁠

⁠Beneath The Red Sky⁠

Takeaways

• “We’re here to dig up the truth, case by case, victim by victim.” – David McLam
• “When you strip away the folklore, you’re left with an older man who took a teenage girl into the woods and returned alone. That’s not mythology. That’s predation.” – David McLam
• “Teresa deserved to be remembered as a person, not a headline.” – LaDonna Humphrey

Behind the Story:

The episode revisits the case of Teresa Beer, a 16-year-old girl who disappeared during a camping trip with a much older man, Welch. When Welch claimed Bigfoot took her, the story captured headlines, diverting attention from the true circumstances of her vanishing. Police built a circumstantial case against Welch, including evidence of drug use and inconsistent stories, but charges were eventually dropped due to insufficient evidence. Welch, described as unstable and prone to wild tales, died years later without confessing, leaving Teresa’s family without answers.

DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE
JOIN ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA BY FOLLOWING THE LINKTREE
Follow Our Family Of True Crime Shows. Every podcast is important. We hope you join us on our important missions!
Lost Girls

True Crime,Authors & Extraordinary People

Beneath The Red Sky

Takeaways

• Examine the impact of sensationalized media on missing persons cases.
• Discuss the legal challenges in prosecuting cases without a body or physical evidence.
• Understand how initial false narratives can complicate investigations.
• Consider the pattern of cases where victims are marginalized and forgotten.
• Anticipate future discussions about Welch’s involvement and new evidence.

Featured Quotes:

• “We’re here to dig up the truth, case by case, Victim by victim. Because they mattered, they still matter, and someone somewhere knows what happened.” - David McClam
• “This was a middle-aged man living mostly off of disability checks who had a reputation for drug use, specifically methamphetamines. He was erratic, paranoid, and fascinated with conspiracy theories.” - LaDonna Humphrey
• “But this wasn’t folklore. This was a missing 16 year old girl.” - LaDonna Humphrey

TimeLine

00:00 A Modern Trail of Tears
01:34 Oklahoma’s Crisis and Systemic Issues
03:52 Historical Context & MMIW Hotspots
05:06 Inadequate Federal Response & Grassroots
07:23 Confronting the Systems & Call to Action

Key Takeaways

• Examine the systemic roots of the MMIW crisis, linking it to historical oppression and modern-day neglect.
• Understand the fragmented jurisdictional issues between state, federal, and tribal authorities that hinder investigations.
• Recognize the alarming statistics: Indigenous women face violence at rates far higher than any other demographic.
• Identify MMIW hotspots, including areas impacted by fracking operations and “man camps.”
• Support grassroots Indigenous-led efforts that are working to fill the void left by inadequate federal responses.

TimeLine

1. Introduction to the MMIW Crisis
2. Historical Context and Systemic Failures
3. Personal Stories and Grassroots Efforts
4. Federal Response and Legislation
5. Call to Action and Conclusion

Featured Quotes

• "A modern trail of tears."
• "It's about genocide, a modern form of it."
• "Oklahoma ranks among the top states for MMIW."
• "The system is not just broken, it's fragmented by design."
• "Indigenous women are murdered at 10 times the national average."

In this episode of Extinguished, hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey delve into the crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW), highlighting the often-overlooked urban aspect of this issue. They discuss alarming statistics, systemic failures in data collection, and the urgent need for community action and advocacy to address these injustices. The conversation emphasizes the importance of recognizing the humanity behind the statistics and calls for better tracking and support for Indigenous communities.

Time Line

00:00 Introduction to MMIW Crisis

00:58 Urban Crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women

03:10 Data Discrepancies and Human Stories

06:09 Call to Action and Community Involvement

Featured Quotes

MMIW is not just a reservation issue; it's an urban crisis.

The FBI's data on missing Indigenous women is alarming.

Many cases of MMIW are underreported or misclassified.

Victims range from infants to elders, with an average age of 29.

Domestic violence and human trafficking are significant factors in MMIW cases.

Law enforcement agencies often fail to provide accurate data.

Families and communities are often left in the dark about missing persons.

There is a need for better coordination and resources for Indigenous-led organizations.

Community involvement is crucial in demanding justice and accountability.

Every missing woman represents a family and a community loss.

Behind the Story: Statistics

In this episode of "Extinguished," hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey delve into the heart-wrenching crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW). This isn't just a story of statistics; it's a narrative of systemic failures and overlooked tragedies that have persisted for centuries.

David and LaDonna guide listeners through the layers of this crisis, revealing how it extends beyond reservations into urban areas, where systems designed to protect and deliver justice are failing. They highlight the staggering discrepancies in data collection and the lack of media coverage, which often leaves these stories untold and these women forgotten.

The episode draws on a landmark report from the Urban Indian Health Institute, which uncovers hundreds of cases of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls, emphasizing that these numbers are likely undercounts. The hosts stress the importance of accurate data and the need for systemic change, urging listeners to support Indigenous-led organizations and demand better from law enforcement and media outlets.

This episode is a call to action, reminding us that every missing woman is more than a statistic. It's about names, faces, and families. David and LaDonna's passionate storytelling ensures that these voices are heard, and their stories are told, until justice is served.

Subscribe now to stay informed and join the fight for justice.

Time Line

• 00:00:01 Introduction to Extinguished
• 00:00:20 The MMIW Crisis Unveiled
• 00:00:56 Historical Context and Colonization
• 00:01:36 Legal Landscape and Jurisdiction Issues
• 00:03:24 Honoring Misty Rainey Bedoni
• 00:05:12 Demanding Justice and Accountability




Featured Quotes

• "The MMIW crisis has been unfolding for centuries."
• "Colonial powers stripped tribal nations of authority."
• "One in three Indigenous women will be raped."
• "Murder is the third leading cause of death."
• "Federal policies normalized violence against Native women."
• "Families search alone for their missing loved ones."
• "Misty Rainey Bedoni's disappearance remains unsolved."
• "Change starts with awareness and truth."
• "The series demands justice and exposes systemic failures."
• "Their lives are not footnotes; they deserve justice."




Behind the Story: Unveiling the MMIW Crisis

In this episode of Extinguished, hosts David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey embark on a deeply personal journey to shed light on the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women (MMIW). The inspiration for this series stems from a shared commitment to justice and a desire to amplify the voices of those who have been silenced for far too long.




David and LaDonna were driven by the alarming statistics and heartbreaking stories that often go unnoticed in mainstream media. Their research revealed a complex web of historical injustices, legal loopholes, and systemic failures that have allowed this crisis to persist for centuries. Determined to bring these issues to the forefront, they meticulously gathered stories, data, and expert insights to paint a comprehensive picture of the MMIW epidemic.




The story of Misty Rainey Bedoni, a Navajo woman who disappeared in 2016, became a focal point for the episode. Her case, like many others, remains unsolved, highlighting the urgent need for awareness and action. Through interviews with family members, advocates, and experts, David and LaDonna aim to honor Misty's memory and demand accountability from the systems that have failed her and countless others.




Creating this episode was not without its challenges. Navigating the emotional weight of the subject matter required sensitivity and care, ensuring that the stories were told with respect and authenticity. David and LaDonna hope that by sharing these narratives, they can inspire listeners to join the fight for justice and help bring about meaningful change.




This episode is more than just a recounting of events; it's a call to action. By understanding the past and acknowledging the present, we can work towards a future where every Indigenous woman is safe, heard, and valued.

Time Line

00:00 Missing in Iowa: Johnny and Eugene
This episode delves into the heartbreaking disappearances of Johnny Gosh (1982) and Eugene Martin (1984), highlighting the striking similarities in their cases. Both were young paperboys for the Des Moines Register, vanished on early Sunday mornings, and left behind abandoned belongings, suggesting a connected pattern of abduction.

03:52 Other Attempted Abductions
The discussion expands to include a series of other attempted abductions of paperboys in the Des Moines area during the 1980s. Incidents involving Jim Pollock, Mike Fackler, and Melissa Gale, among others, suggest a pattern of targeting young carriers, often by men in white vehicles.

07:18 Serial Predator or Pedophile Ring?
The hosts explore whether these incidents point to a single serial predator or a broader pedophile ring, considering the possibility of more than one offender. They also discuss the connection of Mark Allen’s disappearance to these cases and emphasize the lasting impact on the community and families, urging listeners to come forward with any information.

Featured Quotes:

• “We’re here to dig up the truth, case by case, victim by victim.” — David McClam
• “Because they mattered. They still matter. And someone, somewhere knows what happened.” — Ladonna Humphrey
• “If the Indianola incidents were unrelated, that would mean there wasn’t one predator in Iowa during the 1980s. There were two.” — David McClam




Behind the Story:

This episode brings to light the interconnected nature of several missing persons and attempted abduction cases in Iowa during the 1980s. The hosts detail how Johnny Gosch and Eugene Martin’s disappearances share compelling similarities. They also highlight a pattern of other paper carriers being targeted, often by men in white vehicles. The discussion probes the grim possibilities of a single offender, multiple predators, or even an organized ring, painting a picture of a community forever changed by these events.

Time Line

00:00 Introduction: Eugene Martin’s DisappearanceThis segment introduces the podcast and the focus of episode three: the disappearance of 13-year-old paperboy Eugene Martin in 1984. It highlights the podcast’s mission to uncover the truth about missing and murdered individuals, and briefly mentions previous episodes on Mark Allen and Johnny Gosch.

01:16 Eugene Martin Vanishes in Des MoinesThis chapter details the morning of Eugene Martin’s disappearance, where he vanished while delivering newspapers in Des Moines, Iowa. It describes how witnesses saw him talking to an unidentified man or being followed, and the subsequent discovery of his abandoned newspapers.

04:02 Chilling Parallels and Public FearThis section draws striking parallels between Eugene Martin’s disappearance and Johnny Gosch’s case, noting similarities in age, profession, and circumstances. It explores the public’s fear and frustration, the demand for change, and how these cases became symbols of the missing children’s crisis of the 1980s.

05:58 Milk Carton Kids and Lost InnocenceThis chapter discusses the profound impact of these disappearances on society, particularly the loss of childhood innocence and the emergence of campaigns like ‘faces on milk cartons.’ It reflects on a time when children played freely and the subsequent shift to increased caution and awareness of dangers like pedophilia.

07:11 Unanswered Questions and Series ConclusionThis final chapter addresses Eugene Martin’s unsolved case and its connection to Johnny Gosch and Mark Allen, hinting at a potential predator network in Iowa. It also provides a call to action for listeners to come forward with information and promotes the podcast’s upcoming conclusion to the series.

Featured Quotes:

• Ladonna Humphrey: “They mattered. They still matter. And someone, somewhere knows what happened.”
• David McClam: “It was a very innocent time.”
• Ladonna Humphrey: “Suddenly everything felt dangerous. There was no longer safety.”

Behind the Story:

The disappearance of Eugene Martin exacerbated the growing panic surrounding missing children in the 1980s. The similarities between his case and Johnny Gosh’s, both paperboys who vanished in the same area under similar circumstances, led to widespread fear and demands for answers. This episode examines the details of Eugene’s case, the parallels with Johnny’s, and the lasting impact on the community.

Time Line

00:00 Introduction to Johnny Gosch’s Disappearance
01:29 The Morning Johnny Vanished
04:38 Ongoing Theories and Advocacy

Featured Quotes

• David McClam: “Some killers are caught, some walk free, and others hide in plain sight for years, their crimes forgotten, their victims extinguished.”
• Ladonna Humphrey: “…the system failed them.”
• LaDonna Humphrey: “They mattered. They still matter. And someone somewhere knows what happened.”

Key Takeaways

• Understand the details surrounding Johnny Gosch’s disappearance on September 5, 1982, including witness accounts and initial police response.
• Learn how Johnny’s case influenced the creation of the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children and changed law enforcement protocols for handling missing child reports.
• Examine the impact of the “milk carton campaign” and other awareness initiatives sparked by Johnny’s disappearance.
• Consider the controversial claims made by Johnny’s mother, Noreen, regarding potential leads and a possible sighting of Johnny years after his disappearance.
• Reflect on the ongoing search for answers and the broader implications of unsolved missing child cases.




Behind The Story

Johnny Gosch’s disappearance in 1982 sent shockwaves across the nation, prompting significant changes in how law enforcement and the public address cases of missing children. Before Johnny, families often faced delays in reporting a missing child. His case pushed for immediate action and heightened awareness, leading to the creation of Amber Alerts and the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. Despite these advancements, the mystery of what happened to Johnny remains unsolved, a stark reminder of the enduring pain felt by his family and the countless others who have experienced similar tragedies.

TIMELINE

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished Podcast
01:00 Mark Allen’s Disappearance in Iowa
03:34 Mark Allen’s Background and Reclassification
05:19 Johnny Gosch’s Disappearance and Impact
07:49 Missing Boys: The Chilling Timeline

Key Takeaways:

• Understand the details surrounding Mark Allen’s disappearance in Des Moines, Iowa, including the last time he was seen and the initial police response.
• Learn about the case of Johnny Gosh, a 12-year-old paperboy who vanished in 1982, and the impact his disappearance had on the missing children’s movement.
• Recognize the timeline and connections between the disappearances of Mark Allen, Johnny Gosh, and Eugene Martin, and why many suspect a link despite official denials.
• Consider the challenges faced by families of missing children, including delays in police investigations and the emotional toll of unanswered questions.
• Note down the contact information for the Des Moines Police Department for anyone who might have information about Mark Allen’s case: 515-283-4811.

TIMELINE

• 00:00 - Trigger warning and content advisory.
• 00:09 - Introduction to the theme of overlooked victims.
• 00:45 - Welcome to Extinguished and introduction to Tricia Reitler’s case.
• 01:25 - Details of Tricia Reitler’s disappearance and the discovery of evidence.
• 01:55 - The emergence of Larry Hall as a potential suspect.
• 02:21 - Investigation details and challenges faced by law enforcement.
• 03:03 - The impact of Trisha’s disappearance on her family.
• 03:48 - Larry Hall’s background, crimes, and confessions.
• 04:36 - Chris Martin’s investigation and correspondence with Larry Hall.
• 05:21 - Larry Hall’s confessions to other disappearances, including Lori Depies and Paulette Webster.
• 06:24 - Possible connection to the Springfield 3.
• 06:56 - Challenges in verifying Hall’s confessions and the impact on victims’ families.
• 07:59 - Call to action for listeners to provide information.
• 08:40 - Closing remarks and encouragement to support the search for the missing.

Key Takeaways:

Learn about the resources available for reporting information and supporting families of missing persons.

TIMELINE

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:19 The Case of Jessica Roach
02:25 Larry Hall’s Confession
03:40 The Defense’s Argument
04:45 The Court’s Controversial Decision
05:39 Lingering Questions
06:16 Looking Ahead

Key Takeaways:

• Examine the circumstances surrounding Larry Hall’s confession and whether it was truly voluntary.
• Understand the potential impact of excluding expert testimony on false confessions during the trial.
• Consider the ethical implications of using uncorroborated confessions of other alleged crimes to build a case.
• Recognize the importance of providing juries with comprehensive information to assess the validity of confessions.
• Reflect on the unresolved questions and the impact on victims’ families in cases with questionable confessions.

TIMELINE

00:00 Welcome to Extinguished
00:28 The Origins of Larry Duane Hall
01:34 The Early Victims: Naomi Lee Kidder
02:06 More Unsolved Cases: Lolly Chavez and Linda Weldy
03:30 The Disappearances Continue
04:56 The Search for Justice: Michelle Dewey and Lori Deppies
05:27 The Case of Jessica Lynn Roach
06:19 The FBI’s Last Effort
07:33 The Ongoing Search for Answers

Key Takeaways:

• Examine the cases of Naomi Lee Kidder, Lolly Chavez, Linda Weldy, Wendy Felton, Paulette Sue Webster, Michelle Lee Dewey, Lori Jean Deppies, Tricia Reitler, and Jessica Roach, highlighting the details of their disappearances or murders.
• Understand Larry Hall’s potential connection to these cases through confessions, circumstantial evidence, and a map allegedly detailing his victims.
• Recognize the emotional toll on the families and the ongoing search for justice and closure.
• Learn about the FBI’s attempt to gain further information from Hall using a confidential informant.
• Encourage listeners to contact law enforcement with any information related to these cases.

TIMELINE

[00:00:01] Introduction to Extinguished podcast.

• Remember the names and stories of the missing and murdered women.
• Examine the failures within the justice system that left these women vulnerable.
• Understand the potential scope of Larry Hall’s alleged crimes across multiple states.
• Recognize the early warning signs and environmental factors that may have contributed to Hall’s behavior.
• Consider unsolved cases and the ongoing search for answers and justice for victims’ families.

TIMELINE

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:25 Recap of Jason Learrell’s Case
02:12 Theories on Jason’s Disappearance
04:06 The Role of Law Enforcement
05:37 Public Pressure and Advocacy
07:03 A Call to Action

Key Takeaways:

• Understand the key facts of Jason Lierl's disappearance and the scattered nature of his belongings.
• Consider the two possible explanations for the lack of public breakthroughs in the investigation.
• Evaluate the different theories surrounding Jason’s disappearance, including voluntary disappearance, foul play, and accidental overdose.
• Recognize the importance of public pressure, law enforcement updates, and new witnesses in solving the case.
• Remember the $40,000 reward available for information leading to answers in Jason’s case.

TIMELINE

00:00 Welcome to Extinguished
00:25 Recap of Jason Lierl’s Case
01:30 The People in Jason’s Life
02:40 Theories of Voluntary Disappearance
04:35 Investigating the Silence
06:45 The Weight of Secrets
07:41 Call to Action

Key Takeaways:

• Examine the timeline of Jason Lierl’s last known movements and the significance of scattered belongings.
• Consider the potential involvement of people closest to Jason and their silence.
• Evaluate theories surrounding Jason’s disappearance, including voluntary departure and relapse.
• Assess the progress of the law enforcement investigation and possible explanations for the lack of breakthroughs.
• Highlight the importance of public cooperation and available reward funds in solving the case.

In this episode of Extinguished, David McClam and Ladonna Humphrey meticulously trace the last known movements of Jason Lirrell, who disappeared in northwest Arkansas, examining key locations and uncovering inconsistencies in the timeline to seek answers and bring attention to the unsolved missing person case. They dissect the significance of his abandoned car, motorcycle, and scattered belongings, questioning if these elements point to foul play or a deliberate attempt to mislead investigators.

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:25 Tracing Jason’s Last Movements
01:14 The Mystery of the Abandoned Vehicle
02:36 Unraveling the Clues
04:50 The Bigger Picture
06:30 The Search for Answers

Key Takeaways:

• Examine Jason’s last confirmed sighting near Capps Ranches Road and County Road 1101 in Madison County, Arkansas, noting the rural and rugged terrain.
• Analyze the discovery of Jason’s abandoned car in a Fayetteville mall parking lot and consider the implications of its location far from his last known sighting.
• Investigate the whereabouts of Jason’s motorcycle found at an acquaintance’s house in Clifty, Madison County, and discuss how this complicates the timeline.
• Consider the importance of Jason’s personal belongings scattered across Arkansas and Missouri, which suggests deliberate movement of evidence after his disappearance.
• Question who had access to Jason’s vehicles and belongings, emphasizing the need for law enforcement to focus on these connections to solve the case.

In the debut of Extinguished’s new series, hosts David McClam and Ladonna Humphrey investigate the baffling disappearance of Jason Lierl from Madison County, Arkansas, exploring the details surrounding his vanishing and the unanswered questions that haunt his case. Listen as they dissect the timeline, evidence, and potential theories behind Jason’s mysterious absence, seeking to bring his story to light.

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
01:02 Who Was Jason Lierl?
02:25 The Disappearance
03:35 Investigation Insights
04:53 Online Theories and Speculation
05:37 The Human Element

• Examine the initial details of Jason Lierl's background and his last known whereabouts in January 2022.
• Analyze the significance of Jason’s abandoned car and scattered belongings found across Arkansas and Missouri.
• Consider the potential explanations for Jason’s disappearance, including drug relapse and possible foul play.
• Note the involvement of the FBI and the substantial rewards offered for information leading to Jason’s whereabouts.
• Understand the importance of community involvement in solving the case and providing closure to Jason’s family.

• FBI Reward: $30,000 reward for information on Jason Lierl’s whereabouts. [Details Needed]
• Sarah Wood’s Reward: $10,000 reward for information leading to Jason Lierl. [Details Needed]

Timeline:

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:27 The Comparison: Megan Boswell and Casey Anthony
01:44 How the Cases Unfolded
04:13 The Disturbing Discoveries
05:43 Courtroom Outcomes: A Tale of Two Trials
07:29 The Legacy of Evelyn and Kaylee

Key Takeaways:

• Recognize the similarities in the disappearances of Kaylee Anthony and Evelyn Boswell, including delayed reporting and deceptive behaviors of the mothers.
• Understand the critical differences in the courtroom outcomes of Casey Anthony and Megan Boswell, despite the similar circumstances.
• Reflect on the failures within the justice system, emphasizing the importance of continued advocacy for victims of such crimes.
• Consider the devastating impact of lies and deception on investigations and the grieving process.
• Remember Evelyn Boswell and Kaylee Anthony, advocating for justice and awareness to prevent future tragedies.

TIME LINE

• [00:08] Introduction to the Evelyn May Boswell case conclusion.
• [00:36] Details of the trial against Megan Boswell.
• [01:55] The jury’s verdict on all charges.
• [02:30] Discussion of the sentencing trial.
• [03:12] Testimony from Megan Boswell’s mother, Angela Boswell.
• [03:55] Testimony from Megan’s former foster mother, Gail Kite.
• [04:51] Prosecution’s closing arguments.
• [05:38] Defense’s plea for mercy.
• [06:23] The jury’s sentencing decision.
• [07:02] Reflection on the case and its tragic consequences.
• [07:54] Call to action for listeners to report unsolved cases.




KEY TAKEAWAYS

• Understand the impact of deception and neglect in cases of child murder.
• Recognize the complexities of sentencing, considering both justice and potential for redemption.
• Acknowledge the lasting impact of such tragedies on communities and families.
• Learn about the legal proceedings and the emotional toll they take on all involved.
• Emphasize the importance of speaking out and reporting suspicious activity to law enforcement.

Time Line:

00:00 Welcome to Extinguished
01:08 Unveiling Death Fetish
02:03 The Dark Industry of Death Fetish
03:27 Real-Life Consequences
04:11 Revisiting the Investigation
05:01 The Bombshell Revelation
05:40 The Quest for Truth

Key Takeaways:

• Expose the dark underbelly of death fetish and its eroticization of violence against women.
• Understand the scale of death fetish content and the financial incentives driving its production.
• Recognize the potential for fantasy to cross into reality.
• Examine a previous investigation into death fetish and the reasons for reopening the case.
• Learn about “Snuff Princess” Jessica Brown’s claims regarding ownership of death fetish and gore sites.

Chapter Summary:

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:31 The Case of Evelyn Boswell
01:35 Conflicting Stories and Inconsistencies
03:00 The Discovery of Human Remains
04:56 Lessons Learned from a Tragic Case

Featured Quotes:

• David McClam: “…the child whose disappearance was buried under months of lies had been there all along.”
• Ladonna Humphrey: “For months, Evelyn could have been found…maybe, just maybe, there could have been a different outcome.”

Behind the Story:

The Evelyn Boswell case highlights the devastating consequences of delayed reporting and dishonesty in missing persons investigations. The hosts examine how a mother’s false statements and shifting stories wasted precious time, ultimately leading to a tragic outcome that underscores the critical importance of immediate and truthful action when a child’s life is at stake.

If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter Adrienne Hill or any of the other cases please call:

• Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5228
• Crime Stoppers: +1 800-222-TIPS




Chapters

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:19 The Unsolved Cases of Kitsap and Mason Counties
01:46 Barbara Williams: A Chilling Case
02:35 The Murder of Diane Decker
03:05 The Disappearance of Serena Marie Dingler
04:02 A History of Forgotten Cases
05:14 The Importance of Community Involvement






• Recognize the importance of remembering victims of unsolved murders.
• Understand the reasons why some cases remain cold, including lack of evidence and media attention.
• Encourage listeners to contact the Bremerton Police Department or Crime Stoppers with any information.
• Emphasize that justice should be available for all, not just a select few.
• Acknowledge that cold cases can be solved with new information.

If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter nAdrienne Hill, please call:

• Detective Martin Garland, Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5488
• Crime Stoppers Tip Line: +1 800-222-TIPS

Chapters

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:31 A New Development in the Case
01:04 Kenny Hale’s Heartbreak
02:12 The Crime Scene
03:16 DNA Evidence and Its Limitations
04:40 The Nature of the Crime
05:19 The Search for Justice
06:29 Call to Action

Key Takeaways

• Understand the latest DNA evidence in the Nikki Anderson and Adrianne Hill case.
• Recognize the significance of a single name in solving the crime.
• Empathize with Kenny Hale’s decades-long search for justice.
• Learn about the disturbing details of the murders and the betrayal involved.
• Discover how to provide information to Detective Marty Garland or Crime Stoppers.

If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter nAdrienne Hill, please call:

Detective Martin Garland, Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5488

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:29 Kenny Hill’s Heartbreaking Discovery
01:04 A Night of Normalcy Turns Tragic
02:09 The Horrific Discovery
03:25 The Aftermath of the Crime Scene
04:41 Suspicions and Investigations
05:39 A Decade of Waiting for Justice
06:44 Hope Amidst the Grief

Key Takeaways

• Understand the initial police investigation and the impact on Kenny Hill David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey.
• Examine the challenges faced by investigators due to degraded DNA evidence David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey.
• Consider the emotional toll on family members affected by unsolved murder cases David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey.
• Recognize the importance of community involvement in solving cold cases David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey.
• Learn how to report information related to the Nikki Anderson and Adrienne Hill case David McClam, LaDonna Humphrey.

If you have any information about the murder of Helene "Nikki" Anderson and her daughter nAdrienne Hill, please call:

• Detective Martin Garland, Bremerton Police Department: (360) 473-5488

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
00:20 The Victims: Nikki and Adrienne
01:08 The Night of the Tragedy
02:49 Investigation Insights
03:36 Advancements in DNA Technology
04:33 The Impact of Unsolved Crimes

Key Takeaways

• Understand the details surrounding the 1986 murders of Nikki Anderson and Adrienne Hill.
• Learn about the initial suspects and how they were ruled out through alibis and DNA evidence.
• Discover the significance of unidentified DNA found at the crime scene and its potential for solving the case.
• Note the contact information for Detective Martin Garland and how to provide tips.
• Recognize the impact of unsolved cases on families and communities, advocating for continued efforts in seeking justice.

Time Line

00:00 Welcome to Extinguished
00:24 The Heartbreaking Case of Amanda Tussing
02:18 The Investigation Unfolds
03:35 Connecting the Dots
04:32 A Call for Justice
05:00 Previewing the Next Case

• Examine the details surrounding Amanda Tussing’s disappearance and murder in Jonesboro, Arkansas.
• Consider the theory that Amanda may have been pulled over by a police impersonator.
• Analyze the similarities between the murders of Dana Stidham, Amanda Tussing, and Patricia Gordaro.
• Discuss the possibility of a serial killer being responsible for these crimes.
• Encourage listeners to contact law enforcement with any information about these cases.

Her skeletal remains were discovered on September 17, 1989, but due to decomposition, it was unclear if she had been sexually assaulted. Several personal items and groceries were never recovered. Despite evidence collected, including scattered clothing and a magazine found near her belongings, no DNA has led to an arrest.

In 2016, a suspect was named but not charged, and the case remains open with investigators seeking new information. The episode also touches on the upcoming episode on Helene Nikki Anderson’s murder, noting the lack of media coverage for cases involving marginalized communities.

The hosts stress the importance of independent media in highlighting these issues and advocate for solving Dana’s case. They emphasize giving victims a voice and ensuring their stories are remembered.

Key Points:

• Disappearance and Discovery: Dana Stidham disappeared during a routine grocery trip. Her father’s car was found abandoned with evidence suggesting another driver. Her skeletal remains were discovered nearly two months later, with significant decomposition complicating the investigation.

• Unresolved Evidence: Personal items and groceries were missing, and scattered clothing and a magazine were found near the scene. Despite evidence collection, no DNA has led to an arrest, leaving the case cold.

• Suspect and Investigation Status: A suspect was named in 2016, yet no charges have been filed. Investigators continue to seek new leads to solve the case.

• Upcoming Discussions: The episode hints at future coverage of Helene Nikki Anderson’s murder, highlighting the disparity in media attention for cases involving marginalized communities.

• Role of Independent Media: The hosts emphasize the critical role of independent media in bringing attention to underreported cases and advocating for justice. They underscore the importance of giving victims a voice and ensuring their stories are not forgotten.

Listeners are encouraged to engage with the episode and consider the broader implications of media coverage in unsolved cases, particularly those affecting marginalized groups.